As Wales commemorates 25 years of devolution, it’s a timely opportunity to critically assess its numerous shortcomings.

A thorough review indicates significant failures that have not only impeded progress but also cast doubt on the effectiveness of devolution.

Firstly, there is a notable lack of accountability in the Welsh Government, as seen in the rare admissions of error by successive First Ministers, undermining trust in the democratic process.

Additionally, the government has struggled with key infrastructure projects like new hospitals and roads, due to limited expertise and focus.

OTHER NEWS:

Education in Wales continues to lag behind, consistently ranking lowest in the UK and below the OECD average, which is concerning for the nation’s future competitiveness.

The economy’s heavy reliance on public sector employment and subsidies hampers private sector growth and innovation, making it unsustainable.

Wales also faces a significant fiscal deficit, with public expenditure exceeding the UK average by 10%, while revenue lags, threatening economic stability.

Persistent issues in essential services like the NHS and local government show no signs of improvement, overshadowing the supposed benefits of devolution.

The political scene, dominated by the South Wales Labour Party, has led to allegations of complacency and a “client state”, reducing effective opposition and accountability.

Furthermore, the Welsh civil service and civic society seem unprepared for increased self-governance, raising doubts about their capacity to handle more significant powers and responsibilities.

Despite hopes that devolution would boost Welsh democracy and national identity, these have not materialised as expected, with Wales continuing to fall behind other UK regions.

Shockingly, the proposed solution from Cardiff Bay for all this failure, is to simply increase the number of politicians!

After a quarter-century marked by such profound failures, we must question whether devolution truly serves Wales’ best interests or merely perpetuates stagnation. 

The people of Powys, and across Wales, deserve better than continued underperformance and excuses from Cardiff Bay.

We cannot risk another 25 years of failure.
Louise Brown, Llandrindod